domenica 16 dicembre 2012

Changing educational paradigms


During the first day, the 14th December, of the Future of Political Sciences Conference, one of the themes we dealt with was that of education, which I find really interesting and amazing. The speaker who helped us develop the reflection in regards to the paradigms of education was Lynn Mario Menezes de Souza, a Brazilian educator of the Universidade de São Paulo. With reference to his experience in Learning to Read the world through Other Eyes (TOE), an educational project in which he is involved, Mario de Souza underlined the necessity to find an alternative educational paradigm to the present neo-liberal capitalistic hegemonic one in Latin America, which can be considered as the continuation of European colonization in Modernity. With the really interesting expression "Ecology of knowledge", de Souza means the educational model of unlearning privilege and learning from below, educating for dissent in the perspective of multi-naturalism, instead of multi-culturalism. Why? According to our speaker, there is an ethical need to reconcile the educational method to an attitude of listening to the other. Through the conjunction with one's own experience and talking each other, we understand that all knowledges are the same, because each person is "located in a different natural condition", and there's no need for me to feel (or present my cultural model) superior to the other. In fact the consciousness of ourselves is created by the consciousness of differences. If we prefer, "it's starting from 'you' that I know who 'I' am".
The video, created by RSAnimate, I have chosen to link below, shows Ken Robinson's reflection about education and the necessity to change our current paradigms. Take it as a nice cue to reflect more on the theme and to become more critical, even by analyzing our relastionships and the deep sense of our learning. 









The Future of Political and Social Sciences


The symposium that took place on the 14th and 15th December was very interesting and inspiring. It was a unique opportunity to explore issues of living matters and, moreover, to listen to a extraordinary and interdisciplinary group of scholars.
I found incredibly interesting and amazing the contribution given by professor Lynn Mario Menezes de Souza, a Brazilian educator who presented his work based on postcolonial theories. Particularly, he focused his presentation on indigenous knowledges highlighting the method of educating for translating the world. He stressed the importance of educating for dissensus. As a consequence, according to de Souza, in a transcultural context, equivocal translations have to be seen as inputs to build more interconnectivity between mainstream and alternative perspectives. He also underlined the importance of assuming educational policies as non-normative but as instruments for enabling all the capabilities of indigenous knowledges. His presentation reminded me of Augusto Boal and his Theatre of the Oppressed based on the ideas of the Brazilian educator and philosopher Paulo Freire.
Another contribution that I appreciated so much was the analysis presented by professor John Trent. He focused on the future of political studies, stressing the importance of overcoming the scientific and quantitative methodology, as well as the overspecialization, which have made our discipline increasingly irrelevant to public opinion and the political class. He gave us several proposals in order to surmount these problems. Examples of these include inciting young scholars to have a broader knowledge of society and political reality, seeking creative ways to bridge the gaps between our discipline and the media and the general public as well as promoting interaction with politicians and linking the study of politics to explaining human experience and to the study of ethical norms. Furthermore Trent stressed the importance of enhancing hybrid figures which can be responsible for the flowering of knowledge.
What emerged from this international and interdisciplinary event was the urgent importance of rethinking our western concepts in order to understand the complexity of globalization. According to what professor Massimiliano Tomba said in his introduction, globalization is neither something utterly negative nor something completely positive: it is just the condition that gives us the opportunity to rethink our being part of a global society. This is our challenge for the future.

martedì 11 dicembre 2012

Histories of Violence


The video about Saskia Sassen that I published on Sunday is part of the broader project Histories of Violence which is a multi-media forum dedicated to exploring the philosophical, political and aesthetic dimensions of violence. In particular, the video is an excerpt taken from the special series Ten Years of Terror. In this video series, notable scholars explore the legacy of 9/11 and reflect on ten years of terror highlighting the urgent need of thinking about new ethical forms of living together in an inter-connected world. By so doing, ten prominent thinkers give their contributions pursuing the aim of offering a critical reflection about (ten) critical problems related to the consequences of 9/11. On the basis that the political response to 9/11 has been pitiful, this video series tries to overcome conventional and heterodox theories offering great input to a fundamental issue.
It is undeniable that, especially after 9/11, we are facing a continuous state of exception where questions of individual rights are rejected in the name of public security. Governments claim extensions of power in order to legitimate their actions and, by doing so, they operate outside of the laws extending their power to people who are no longer considered as human beings and whose rights automatically disappear.
I find historiesofviolence.com a really interesting project as it offers a multidisciplinary approach to the crucial problem of violence. In particular, I have appreciated some of the introductory lectures about important philosophers whose work is particularly relevant for the concept of violence as well as the interview with the American artist Robert Longo who works on themes of (state) power and (human) violence.



Ten Years of Terror: Guggenheim Edit from HISTORIES OF VIOLENCE on Vimeo.

domenica 9 dicembre 2012

Modern tyranny

In view of the event about the future of political and social sciences, I would like to focus on Saskia Sassen who is one of the speakers that will be at the conference on the 14th December. She is a Dutch sociologist and professor of Sociology at Columbia University. Her work focuses on globalization analyzed from social, economic and political point of view. In particular, she studies the impacts of globalization on urban life as well as the effects of increasing transnationalism; she is also particularly interested in exploring the field of new technologies and their interaction with global governance. She has recently focused on denationalization and global human migration.
In this video she talks about how imperialist powers rob people of the opportunity to develop their own economies. She compares this imperialist habit to a sort of tyranny that reduces aided people to children.
Sassen criticizes a typical western tendency which tries to export and impose western models to the rest of the world. According to what she says, this continuous activity of exporting western systems has wrecked a lot of land in certain parts of the world (e.g. Sub-Saharan Africa) and, what is more, it has wrecked a lot of traditional economies pursuing the western aim of modernization and unlimited growth. By so doing, western imperialist powers prevent traditional economies from using their own indigenous knowledge in order to overcome their inefficiency in their own way, which does not necessarily mean that they have to embrace the western paradigm based on full production efficiency and modern growth.
I think this video can help us with our effort to overcome the Eurocentric perspective. We are facing new global challenges and I am pretty sure that it is time to abandon dangerous paradigms that present western culture as the only model of civilization.


domenica 2 dicembre 2012

Harvey Milk's "The Hope Speech"

The speech I chose to analyze is The Hope Speech, which was delivered by Harvey Milk in 1978, the same year of his death. Important american LGBT rights activist, Milk became the first openly gay person to be elected to public office in California. The central theme of this speech, whose message is valid nowadays, is that of the fight for the rights of LGBT people, who are asked to find again the hope and the determination in order to think about a better future. But his speech's addressees are also non-LGBT people. All people should unite to destroy all discriminations that characterize our societies.
As the website from which I have taken the speech says, "his message not only challenges our willingness to embrace and celebrate our differences, but it offers a message of hope. His untimely and tragic death serves as a reminder that we still have a very long way to go".




Critical Discourse Analysis

On December 6, 2011 the American Secretary of State Hilary Clinton delivered a speech before the United Nations Human Rights Council in recognition of Human Rights Day celebrated on December 10. During her speech she focused on human rights for LGBT people highlighting that gay rights are human rights and remarking the activity of the Obama Administration in tackling international abuses of LGBT people. Her speech was hailed by the international LGBT community as a historic remark about enhancing and securing the rights of LGBT people.
Far from considering the American Secretary of State Hilary Clinton an innovative thinker, I chose this speech mainly for two reasons: firstly because it is a functional example for our aim of making a critical discourse analysis and secondly because I think that it deals with a very important and fundamental issue.


giovedì 29 novembre 2012

Another Face Project


Self Evident Truths is a photographic documentation of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community across American cities in an effort to raise awareness about equality. The project is based on taking portraits of anyone who is, or ever has been, anything other than 100% straight.
It is another photo project that deals with faces of unseen people.



giovedì 15 novembre 2012

Turning the world inside out


On march 2011 the French photographer JR received the TED prize due to his worth spreading idea of turning the world inside out.
JR’s work started when he was a teenager: he loved to mark the public spaces of Paris with his graffiti telling the world that he existed. After few years he started taking photos of unseen people telling the world that they existed.
He bases his work on taking photos of unguarded people with a 28 millimetres wide angle lens, blowing the images up and pasting them up on public spaces like buildings, buses, trains, walls, rooftops, bridges...
He began his work in Paris in 2004 photographing people who lived in the suburbs of Paris; he then continued his project until 2006 taking photos of the protagonists of the Clichy-sous-Bois riots. His photos were firstly illegally pasted up on the walls of some neighbouring suburbs and then the Paris City Hall decided to wrap its buildings with these photos, making an official exhibition.


In 2007 JR realized what he himself called the biggest illegal art exhibition ever: the Face to Face project. He decided to take portraits of Palestinians and Israelis doing the same jobs (hairdressers, actors, musicians, taxi drivers, teachers) and to post their huge portraits face to face in eight Palestinian and Israeli cities and on both sides of the Separation Wall. Palestinian and Israeli men and women who were asked to laugh and to make faces in front of JR’s lens all accepted to be posted together on unavoidable places on the Israeli and Palestinian side.


In 2008 he realized another amazing art project called Women are Heroes. JR went to Africa, South America, India and Cambodia with the aim of making all the unseen women visible. He asked women to tell him about their lives and then to let him take a picture of their faces. Despite having suffered all kind of horrors and crimes, they accepted to become protagonists of JR’s project. JR asked men to pay a tribute to women by posting the photos everywhere in the cities. In January 2009 two thousand square meters of rooftops were covered with women's eyes and faces of Kiberia, one of the largest slums in Kenya. With his project, JR took women’s stories around the world and in 2010 his activity of revealing an invisible humanity turn into a movie that was part of the official selection of the Cannes film festival.


In 2011 JR launched a worldwide project that has involved nearly more than eighty thousand protagonists until now. JR called it the Inside Out Project. During the TED prize conference he called for the creation of a global art project saying he wished for us to stand up for what we care about by participating in a global art project in order to turn the world inside out together. The project pursues the aim of giving everyone the opportunity to share their portrait with the world and promoting a statement they stand for. Anyone can take part in this huge project by uploading an image that will be made into poster and sent back to the project’s co-creators. They can then exhibit it in their own communities. People can participate either as an individual or in a group and posters can be pasted up anywhere.
Inside Out first testing ground was Tunisia after the Arab Spring. Tunisian people made hundreds of posters replacing the portrait of the ruler (that had been for fifty years the only portrait in the streets) by their own portraits. Afterwards Inside Out has spread all around the world, from Pakistan to North Dakota, from Iran to Mexico and thousands of people have used it as a platform for their protests.


JR’s work is an amazing example of how art can contribute to change our perception of the world. By revealing parts of humanity that are usually and  sometimes intentionally hidden, JR’s art is somehow a new form of Realism (like the one of Gustave Courbet in the XIX century). Not only does he represent people but he also lets them speak about themselves and their lives. He does not use art in a self-referential way but he gives art a social meaning and a social action in the perspective of turning the world inside out.


If you want to read more about JR and his projects, these are some useful links:

domenica 11 novembre 2012

Occupy Wall Street, a new society in miniature

Occupy Wall Street is a people-powered movement which began on September 17, 2011 in Liberty Square in Manhattan’s Financial District, has spread to over 100 cities in the US and actions in over 1,500 cities globally. The aim of this movement, inspired by egyptian and tunisian uprisings, is to fight against the destructive power of banks and multinational companies, those responsibles of the economic and financial crisis that has affected our world since October 2008. The owners of the great financial capitals represent the richest 1% of people that are ruling an unequitable global economy, with corrosive consequences for the future of the remainig 99% of people of the world.
We are going to focus on some interesting aspects of Occupy Wall Street movement, which has a lot to teach to european political and social movements, through the ideas of David Graeber, an anthropologist at Goldsmiths, University of London and one of the initial organizers of the protests.  
First, we should consider that this movement highlights the self-assertion of a new generation of Americans with no job and no prospectives for the future. It does not suprises us that these people would like to head towards the financial magnates who stole their future. The fundamental reflection of people involved in that protest concerns all lies free traders told us about capitalism. As David Graeber in an article written for The Guardian: “Markets did not run themselves; creators of financial instruments were not infallible geniuses; and debts did not really need to be repaid – in fact, money itself was revealed to be a political instrument, trillions of dollars of which could be whisked in or out of existence overnight if governments or central banks required it. Even the Economist was running headlines like "Capitalism: Was it a Good Idea?". And furtherly, we should be aware of the fact that “the rulers of global economy” has been always concerned about persuading us, especially through the so-called "corporate media", that the actual economic system, deeply hierarchical and generating social inequality and oppression of human beings and destruction of nature, is the only imaginable. 

What every social people-powered movement should do, is to call into question the actual economic system, with the strong conviction that capitalism cannot be reformed, but only destroyed from below.


What about Occupy Wall Street’s roots? OWS is one of the few movements in american history to be founded on anarchist principles. First, the refusal to regognise the legitimacy of existing legal order and political institutions, from which results the praxis of direct action, better than appeals to the authorities. Direct action “is a matter of acting as if the existing structure of power does not even exist”.
Secondly, OWS organizers decided to operate by direct democracy and consensus, so as to avoid a situation in which there would be a formal leadership and a majority obliges minorities to accept its point of view. The background idea is that if we refuse all forms of decision-making operating with coercive enforcement, our decision have necessarily to be made by general consent.
Finally, the encampments, and in general the entire OWS esperience, had been a testing ground of a new kind of social relations, based on principles such as mutual aid and self-organization. The success of this experiment is closely connected to people’s awareness that the actual global political system is irreparably corrupt. “If we are to live in any sort of genuinely democratic society - says Graeber - we're going to have to start from scratch - clearly struck a profound chord in the American psyche”.
To conclude, I wish european and italian political and social movements will consider Occupy Wall Street movement as a sort of model of organization from below, especially for what concerns non-coercive decision-making and free social relations.


Sources and useful materials:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPeaFKvszKI
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2011/11/2011112872835904508.html
http://bjsonline.org/2011/12/understanding-the-occupy-movement-perspectives-from-the-social-sciences/

sabato 10 novembre 2012

Voting for the lesser of two evils?


At the end of September 2012 Noam Chomsky was interviewed on the Matthew Filipowicz Show. During his interview Chomsky discussed, among other things, the 2012 Election focusing on the debate that took place among some sections of the American progressive public opinion. The question carried by this debate was whether to vote in swing States for President Obama or not. Chomsky explained that if he was a person in a swing State, he would have vote against Romney only to keep the right-wing out from the White House. He exactly said: “Between the two choices that are presented there's, I think, some significant differences and if I was personally in a swing State, I’d vote against Romney/Ryan which means voting for Obama ‘cause there’s no other choice”. And he continued like this: “I happen to be in a non-swing State so I can either not vote or, as I probably will, vote for Jill Stein, Green candidate, in the hope that it might be the beginning of some genuine electoral alternative over time”. According to what the cofounder of the online activism group RootsAction.org, Jeff Cohen, has recently said, Roots Action sent an email to its members asking them to do exactly what Noam Chomsky had said. Roots Action itself is a strong opponent of the Democrats but, as Cohen said, the Republicans would had been worse in almost every regard than Obama so it was necessary not to let them come back to power. Both Chomsky and Cohen asked people who were in a safe state to vote for a green or another third party in order to get over the dualism Democrats-Republicans in the perspective of a society change. On the other hand Cheri Honkala, who was the Green Party’s nominee for vice-president in the 2012 election, said that there was no point in voting the less of two evils: it was necessary to stop arguing about who had got the worst seat on the Titanic and get organized to get off this Titanic.
I agree with Chomsky and Cohen: unfortunately, there were no possibilities for the Green Party to win so I think that people in swing States should have held their noses pursuing the aim of keeping Romney/Ryan away from the White House. Republicans could have been with no doubts a terrible solution, they could have been more racist, more militaristic and, in a few words, more dangerous. In 2008 elections Chomsky said that there was worth expending some effort to prevent the Republican’s rise to power voting for Obama but without illusions about the Democrats and their alternatives. In 2012 election he said, more or less, the same things. I think this means that there is something deeply and wrongly inherent in the general socio-economic-political system that needs to be changed. I find the solution suggested by Chomsky a good way to try changing the consciousness of people and society: an effort to build more awareness and more responsibility in a (hyper)modern society that tries to produce blind men and women totally and unconsciously irresponsible.
You can watch the debate between Jeff Cohen and Cheri Honkala here:
If you want to listen the full interview of Noam Chomsky, this is the URL of the youtube video:

lunedì 5 novembre 2012

Few words to present the blog description video


Just few words to describe the contest in which the blog description video was developed:
the video “First as Tragedy, Then as Farce” is part of an animation series promoted by the Royal Society of Arts (RSA), a British Institution founded in 1754. Its purpose is to develop and promote new ways of thinking about human achievement and social progress. The RSA tries to create platforms for critical debates and new ideas in order to translate these new forms of thinking into practical action and social change. Furthermore, the RSA bases its work on a national and international network (the RSA Fellowship) that takes part in a worldwide sphere of activity.
In pursuing the aim of finding innovative solutions to social challenges, the RSA holds a free lectures program run by some notable lecturers (in our case, the lecture where the video is taken from was run by the Slovenian philosopher Slavoj Zizek). These lectures are made available on its website. Some of them, like the video posted on our blog, are then translated into cartoon animations by Andrew Park.
I find this animation series (that consists of fourteen parts) definitely brilliant, aesthetically pleasing and cleverly funny. I think that this is an innovative way of presenting ideas that the RSA itself describes as “the world-changing ideas”.
If you want to learn more about RSA or about the animation series, these are some useful links:

venerdì 26 ottobre 2012

Blog description

We have planned to create a blog that focuses on some contemporary free thinkers like philosophers, anthropologists, historians.
We would like to follow some of these notable thinkers in order to outline their thoughts in the perspective of a social change. Particularly, we are going to focus on what they think, write or say referring to themes of topical interest.
The main protagonists of our blog are going to be Noam Chomsky, David Graeber, Slavoj Zizek but many others are going to support them in our effort to explore some horizons of change.