sabato 10 novembre 2012

Voting for the lesser of two evils?


At the end of September 2012 Noam Chomsky was interviewed on the Matthew Filipowicz Show. During his interview Chomsky discussed, among other things, the 2012 Election focusing on the debate that took place among some sections of the American progressive public opinion. The question carried by this debate was whether to vote in swing States for President Obama or not. Chomsky explained that if he was a person in a swing State, he would have vote against Romney only to keep the right-wing out from the White House. He exactly said: “Between the two choices that are presented there's, I think, some significant differences and if I was personally in a swing State, I’d vote against Romney/Ryan which means voting for Obama ‘cause there’s no other choice”. And he continued like this: “I happen to be in a non-swing State so I can either not vote or, as I probably will, vote for Jill Stein, Green candidate, in the hope that it might be the beginning of some genuine electoral alternative over time”. According to what the cofounder of the online activism group RootsAction.org, Jeff Cohen, has recently said, Roots Action sent an email to its members asking them to do exactly what Noam Chomsky had said. Roots Action itself is a strong opponent of the Democrats but, as Cohen said, the Republicans would had been worse in almost every regard than Obama so it was necessary not to let them come back to power. Both Chomsky and Cohen asked people who were in a safe state to vote for a green or another third party in order to get over the dualism Democrats-Republicans in the perspective of a society change. On the other hand Cheri Honkala, who was the Green Party’s nominee for vice-president in the 2012 election, said that there was no point in voting the less of two evils: it was necessary to stop arguing about who had got the worst seat on the Titanic and get organized to get off this Titanic.
I agree with Chomsky and Cohen: unfortunately, there were no possibilities for the Green Party to win so I think that people in swing States should have held their noses pursuing the aim of keeping Romney/Ryan away from the White House. Republicans could have been with no doubts a terrible solution, they could have been more racist, more militaristic and, in a few words, more dangerous. In 2008 elections Chomsky said that there was worth expending some effort to prevent the Republican’s rise to power voting for Obama but without illusions about the Democrats and their alternatives. In 2012 election he said, more or less, the same things. I think this means that there is something deeply and wrongly inherent in the general socio-economic-political system that needs to be changed. I find the solution suggested by Chomsky a good way to try changing the consciousness of people and society: an effort to build more awareness and more responsibility in a (hyper)modern society that tries to produce blind men and women totally and unconsciously irresponsible.
You can watch the debate between Jeff Cohen and Cheri Honkala here:
If you want to listen the full interview of Noam Chomsky, this is the URL of the youtube video:

Nessun commento:

Posta un commento